Evaluation on Forest Park Landscape Resources Based on AHP-LCJ

Abstract

Abstract: The AHP-LCJ method was used to recognize both the public and the professionals as the main appraisal body. A multi-level appraisal was conducted for the quality of the forest park scenery resources in Wuxie country forest park. The results show that in the whole forest park and scenic appraisal,the public has obtained the high consistency with the professionals. As for scenic spot appraisal,there is a high similarity but with a considerable difference. According to the analysis on the main reason of the difference,forest park's scenery resource appraisal should use the AHP-LCJ and at the same time,consider the public's tourism demand.

Key words: Analytic Hierarchy Process, Law of Comparative Judgement, landscape resources evaluation, structure model of evaluation, weight of evaluation indicator, forestry park

CLC Number:

S759.91
P964

CHEN Chuwen, BAO Qinxing, FENG Juhao. Evaluation on Forest Park Landscape Resources Based on AHP-LCJ[J]. FOREST RESOURCES WANAGEMENT, 2009, (5): 99-104.

References

[1]欧阳勋志,廖为明,彭世揆.论森林风景资源质量评价与管理[J].江西农业大学学报,2004,26(2):169-173.
[2]Hull IV R B. Measurement of scenic beauty: the law of comparative judgement and scienic beauty estimation procedures[J]. Forest Science,1984,30(4):1084-1096.
[3]陈鑫峰,王雁.国内外森林景观的定量评价和经营技术研究现状[J].世界林业研究,2000,13(5):31-38.
[4]王云才,王书华.景观旅游规划设计核心三力要素的综合评价[J].同济大学学报:自然科学版,2007,35(12):1724-1728.
[5]Hull IV R B,Buhyoff G J. The scenic beauty temporal distribution method: An attempt tomake scenic beauty assessment compatible with forest planning efforts[J]. Forest Science,1986,32(2):271-286.
[6]Buhyoff G J,Leuschner W A,Arndt L K. Replication of a scenic preference function[J]. Forest Science,1980,26(2):227-230.
[7]刘勇,韩泰凡,曲新谱,等.基于层次分析法的绵山旅游资源评价与可持续发展对策[J].经济地理,2006,26(02):346-348.
[8]Hull IV R B,Buhyoff G J,Gordell H K. Psychophysical models: an example with scenic beauty perceptions of roodside pine forests[J]. Landscape Journal,1987,6(2):113-122.
[9]Buhyoff G J,Leuschner W A. Estimation psychological disutility from damaged forest stands[J]. Forest Science,1978,24(1):424-432.
[10]GB/T 18005-1999,中国国家森林公园风景资源质量等级评定标准[S].
[11]Buhyoff G J,Gautheir L J,Wellman J D. Predicting scenic quality for urban forests using vegetation measurement[J]. Forest Science,1984,30(2):71-82.
[12]Tips W E J,Savasdisar T. The influence of the environmental background of subjects on their landscape preference evaluation[J]. Langdscape and Urban Planning,1986,13(1):125-133.
[13]俞孔坚. 自然风景景观评价方法[J].中国园林,1986,2(3):38-40.

[1]	CHEN Xuan, LU Peng, TIAN Yingjia, YANG Ting, YUAN Hedi, WANG Hua, SUN Qian. Calculation method of forestland quota occupation during the 15th Five-Year Plan period—Taking Guizhou Province as an example [J]. Forest and Grassland Resources Research, 2025, 0(6): 121-131.
[2]	ZHANG Xiaoyuan, LI Le, PEI Nancai, GAO Bingtao, HAO Zezhou, ZOU Jingyuan, CUI Kai, WANG Li. Construction of evaluation index system for damage of forest ecological services and functions in Guangdong Province using the analytic hierarchy process (AHP) [J]. Forest and Grassland Resources Research, 2025, 0(4): 112-121.
[3]	ZHAO Li, ZHANG Haidong, LIU Shanghua, WANG Meizhen, SANG Hao, LI Jiatao, WANG Fude. Introduction performance of nine Picea species in Hohhot [J]. Forest and Grassland Resources Research, 2025, 0(2): 109-116.
[4]	QIAO Yi’na, CAO Shuangcheng, SHI Mengdi, DANG Hongzhong, QIN Yuqian, ZHAO Xiaobin, GAO Rong, SHI Changchun. Health Assessment System of Forest Shelterbelts in Yulin Sandy Region of Mu Us Based on Analytic Hierarchy Process [J]. Forest and Grassland Resources Research, 2024, 0(2): 109-115.
[5]	ZHOU Long, YANG Xiaoxue, DUAN Xiaochen. Comprehensive Adaptability Evaluation of Six Kinds of Landscapeing Plants in Semi-arid Region [J]. Forest and Grassland Resources Research, 2024, 0(1): 73-81.
[6]	TAN Ying, XU Jun, LIN Congcong, WANG Ke, WANG Wenwu, CHEN Chunlei. Study on the Comprehensive Value Evaluation of Ancient and Famous Tree Resources in Zhejiang Province Based on Analytic Hierarchy Process [J]. FOREST RESOURCES WANAGEMENT, 2023, 0(4): 169-178.
[7]	JIANG Xuwang, YU Shuhan, LI Yihui, ZHAN Liyu. Research on Evaluation of Elderly Healing Forest Wellness Base [J]. FOREST RESOURCES WANAGEMENT, 2023, 0(3): 71-79.
[8]	LUO Dan, WANG Qingfei, CHAO Bixiao, LI Le, HAO Zezhou, LU Yuan, WANG Cheng, WU Ruichen, LIU Feipeng, PEI Nancai. Evaluation on Fire Risk Rating of Forest Stands in Wildland-Urban Interface—A Case Study of Guangzhou City [J]. FOREST RESOURCES WANAGEMENT, 2023, 0(3): 56-64.
[9]	LIU Lijie, XIE Zhuohong, LEI Ming, SHI Yuemou, LI Shengqiang, LIU Ping. Evaluation of Forest Quality Based on Analytic Hierarchy Process —A Case Study in Liuxihe Forest Farm,Guangzhou [J]. FOREST RESOURCES WANAGEMENT, 2022, 0(6): 89-94.
[10]	HAO Min, TANG Hui, WANG Manlian, LIU Baoyu, CHEN Yujiao. Evaluation and Screening of Ornamental Illicium difengpi Germplasm in Terms of Leaf Morphology Using Analytic Hierarchy Process Method [J]. FOREST RESOURCES WANAGEMENT, 2022, 0(5): 136-144.
[11]	HU Jiayi, WANG Ruihui, LIU Kaili, ZHANG Bin, ZHOU Yuhuai, LI Xuehui, GONG Yingyun. Effects of Thinning on Ecological Benefits of Cryptomeria fortunei Plantations in High Altitude Area of Western Sichuan [J]. FOREST RESOURCES WANAGEMENT, 2022, 0(4): 80-88.
[12]	Zhipeng XIAO, Polang LIU, Ye LIU, Fangwen HU, Huaizhen PENG, Ziyan ZHANG, Ping GAO. Evaluation and Selection of Potential Scenic View-point Distribution Areas Based on GIS and Fuzzy Analytic Hierarchy Process —An Example from Jiulangshan Mountain Park in Zhuzhou [J]. FOREST RESOURCES WANAGEMENT, 2020, 0(1): 158-165.
[13]	PENG Chucai, DIAN Yuanyong, ZHOU Zhixiang, CHENG Weijin, XIAO Zhiyan, DONG Lian, LI Xinyu. Quality Evaluation and Analysis on Factors Affecting the Quality of the Forest Belt Around Wuhan City [J]. FOREST RESOURCES WANAGEMENT, 2019, 0(6): 75-83.
[14]	MENG Meng, MA Jianzhang, JI Jianwei, ZHOU Xiaorui, HU Xinxin. Comprehensive Evaluation and Analysis of Chinese Wildlife Hometown Operation [J]. FOREST RESOURCES WANAGEMENT, 2019, 0(3): 30-35.
[15]	SUN Yu, LI Jiping, CAO Xiaoyu, XU Zhanyong. Comprehensive Evaluation of Soil Fertility of Cunninghamia lanceolata Ecological Public Welfare Forests in Different Age Groups [J]. FOREST RESOURCES WANAGEMENT, 2019, 0(1): 57-62.